Trade secrets defined

What is a trade secret, and how is it different from a patent?

There is no single definition. Each state has its own version, and the Defend Trade Secrets Act — the only federal statute governing trade secret protection — has its own. But the definitions agree on the essentials: information that has value because it is not generally known, and that its owner takes reasonable measures to keep secret.

Most projects near the end of their R&D lifecycle are trade secrets: they have inherent value to the company and have not yet been made public through the patent prosecution process.

How does federal law define a trade secret?

All forms and types of financial, business, scientific, technical, economic, or engineering information, including patterns, plans, compilations, program devices, formulas, designs, prototypes, methods, techniques, processes, procedures, programs, or codes, which the owner has taken reasonable measures to keep secret, and which derive independent economic value, actual or potential, from not being generally known to, and not being readily ascertainable through proper means by, another person who can obtain economic value from the disclosure or use of the information.

Paraphrasing the Defend Trade Secrets Act of 2016, 18 U.S.C. § 1839(3)

Two conditions do all the work in that definition. The information must have value because it is secret, and the owner must have taken reasonable measures to keep it that way. Fail the second and a court may decide you never had a trade secret at all — which is why documented protection is the whole game. See how Crown Jewel® builds the evidence of reasonable measures.

Trade secret or patent: which protection fits which asset?

The two forms of IP are opposites. One protects by disclosure, the other by secrecy.

Trade secret

  • Registration: none. The only form of IP unregistered with any authority.
  • Disclosure: none. Know-how is kept secret to protect its value from discovery and use by others.
  • Term: unlimited. Retains status as long as it provides competitive advantage and remains secret.
  • Proof: a litigation right. Designated a trade secret only when enforcement rights are litigated.
  • Best for: anything that cannot be reverse-engineered from the product — formulas, algorithms, model weights, processes, data, strategy.
  • Examples: the WD-40 formula and the Coca-Cola recipe, both decades old.

Patent

  • Registration: public, with the USPTO.
  • Disclosure: total. The application must detail exactly what is being patented, with schematics and design details, in a searchable online database.
  • Term: limited (generally 20 years from filing).
  • Proof: the granted patent — if it is granted. Applications are frequently rejected outright, leaving the applicant with neither a patent nor a secret.
  • Best for: anything that would be relatively easy to reverse-engineer once released or sold to a customer.
  • Risk: full disclosure lets competitors design around the claims with changes that may not infringe.

How do courts decide whether information is a trade secret?

Because trade secrets are an unregistered litigation right, there is no set-in-stone predetermination of what qualifies. For over a century, much of the case law in the United States has relied on the six-factor test from the Restatement of Torts. Every factor is a question about evidence — which is why Crown Jewel®’s advisory work is built around producing it.

Almost every company has a few trade secrets; some have many. Companies with a significant patent portfolio almost always have a robust trade secret portfolio as well — but those assets have very likely never been identified as trade secrets, let alone valued.

  1. The extent to which the information is known outside the business.
  2. The extent to which it is known by employees and others involved in the business.
  3. The extent of measures taken to guard the secrecy of the information.
  4. The value of the information to the business and to its competitors.
  5. The amount of effort or money expended in developing the information.
  6. The ease or difficulty with which the information could be properly acquired or duplicated by others.

Trade secret frequently asked questions

The questions boards, founders, and counsel ask first.

How is a trade secret different from a patent?

A trade secret is the only form of IP that is unregistered with any authority; it is never designated a trade secret until enforcement rights are litigated. Trade secrets are know-how kept secret to protect their inherent value from discovery and use by others. A patent is publicly registered with the USPTO and must disclose exactly what is being patented, with schematics and design details — all of it in a searchable online database, which leaves every patent open to being copied with changes that may not violate its protections. Trade secrets also have no expiration date: they keep their status as long as they provide competitive advantage and remain secret. The WD-40 formula and the Coca-Cola recipe are famous trade secrets that are decades old.

Why not patent a trade secret to protect it?

A patent application requires the owner to reveal every aspect and nuance of the invention. Because the USPTO database is easily searchable, others can see that information and attempt a substantially similar creation of their own. Applications are also frequently rejected outright, leaving the applicant with zero protection — neither a patent nor the protection of having kept the information closely held. Generally speaking, companies should patent what would be relatively easy to reverse-engineer once released or sold to a customer, and keep the rest as trade secrets.

Does my organization have trade secrets?

Almost every company has a few; some have many. Companies with a significant patent portfolio almost always have a robust trade secret portfolio too, but it is very likely those assets have been neither identified as trade secrets nor valued. The most valuable trade secrets are the ones with the greatest potential to drive earnings or save money through the efficiencies they bring, and that took the most time and resources to develop. The more valuable the secret, the stronger the security around it needs to be. Because trade secrets are a litigation right rather than a registration, US courts have relied for over a century on the six-factor test above.

How do you establish the value of a trade secret?

Several established accounting methods are used every day for tax reporting and strategy, M&A, and other purposes. In lay terms, they consider the time and money a company spends developing the unique know-how — including the “negative know-how” created by the wrong turns along the way — plus the expected future sales or savings over the asset’s useful life, discounted for competitive and market forces and brought to net present value. For insurance, Crown Jewel® offers three insured-value bases: R&D cost, 2× R&D cost, or full market value with an independent valuation.

Can the value of a trade secret be insured?

Yes — now it can. InnovationGuard™ from Crown Jewel® Insurance is the first insurance policy ever devised to insure the value of a trade secret. Crown Jewel®’s advisory and due diligence process helps you identify the trade secret, quantify its value (historic and ongoing), and put reasonable measures in place so you are ready to enforce after a covered loss. When an event occurs, the policy funds investigation and recovery — injunctive relief, damages, or criminal referral — first as part of “respond and recover,” and then through subrogation as necessary. If the asset cannot be recovered, the policy pays its pre-agreed value.

Find out which of your assets already qualify.

Take a short, confidential Trade Secret Protection assessment to get your score and schedule a free advisory call with CJI senior leadership.